| Shooter's Grove Primary School152366 | Primary | — | — | — |
| Sheffield Springs Academy131896 | Secondary | Good | 60.6% | 1,083 |
| Sheffield Park Academy131895 | Secondary | Good | 57.5% | 1,185 |
| Sheffield Inclusion Centre137596 | Not applicable | Good | 80.6% | 211 |
| Sheffield High School Gdst107166 | Not applicable | — | — | 695 |
| Sheffield Hallam University133871 | Not applicable | — | — | — |
| Sharrow Nursery, Infant and Junior School152367 | Primary | — | — | — |
| Seven Hills School151685 | Not applicable | — | — | — |
| Sacred Heart School, A Catholic Voluntary Academy140439 | Primary | Good | 19.5% | 200 |
| Royd Nursery and Infant School107057 | Primary | Good | 19.9% | 207 |
| Rivelin Primary School107081 | Primary | Good | 19.0% | 379 |
| Reignhead Primary School107077 | Primary | Good | 34.0% | 223 |
| Rainbow Forge Primary Academy143997 | Primary | Good | 47.0% | 347 |
| Pye Bank CofE Primary School146841 | Primary | Good | 60.2% | 446 |
| Prince Edward Primary School107090 | Primary | Good | 46.1% | 439 |
| Porter Croft Church of England Primary Academy139986 | Primary | Good | 41.3% | 214 |
| Pipworth Community Primary School134751 | Primary | Good | 60.2% | 379 |
| Phoenix School of Therapeutic Education142912 | Not applicable | — | — | 25 |
| Phillimore Community Primary School143798 | Primary | Good | 55.4% | 408 |
| Parson Cross Church of England Primary School107107 | Primary | Good | 30.0% | 203 |
| Paces School for Conductive Education135815 | Not applicable | Good | 26.4% | 61 |
| Owler Brook Primary School147622 | Primary | Good | 71.2% | 411 |
| Outwood Academy City140415 | Secondary | Requires Improvement | 44.2% | 1,138 |
| Oughtibridge Primary School145832 | Primary | Outstanding | 9.0% | 411 |
| Oasis Academy Watermead140219 | Primary | Good | 55.4% | 423 |
| Oasis Academy Fir Vale140218 | Primary | Good | 83.4% | 389 |
| Oasis Academy Don Valley140394 | All-through | Good | 67.6% | 1,116 |
| Notre Dame High School138361 | Secondary | Good | 18.3% | 1,491 |
| Norton Free Church of England Primary School107106 | Primary | Good | 19.0% | 210 |
| Norfolk Community Primary School145413 | Primary | Good | 62.6% | 469 |
| Nook Lane Junior School146012 | Primary | Good | 16.3% | 252 |
| Newfield Secondary School140821 | Secondary | Good | 36.3% | 1,048 |
| Netherthorpe Primary School107043 | Primary | Good | 51.9% | 257 |
| Nether Green Junior School107004 | Primary | Good | 13.1% | 375 |
| Nether Green Infant School107029 | Primary | Good | 9.7% | 186 |
| Nether Edge Primary School142274 | Primary | Outstanding | 28.4% | 478 |
| Mylnhurst Preparatory School and Nursery107165 | Not applicable | — | — | 176 |
| Mundella Primary School152088 | Primary | Good | 12.5% | 417 |
| Mossbrook School107182 | Not applicable | Good | 54.5% | 176 |
| Mosborough Primary School107039 | Primary | Outstanding | 14.1% | 417 |
| Monteney Primary School139544 | Primary | Good | 36.5% | 446 |
| Meynell Nursery & Primary School139336 | Primary | Good | 68.3% | 482 |
| Mercia School145897 | Secondary | Outstanding | 24.4% | 1,070 |
| Meersbrook Bank Primary School107002 | Primary | Good | 9.4% | 229 |
| Meadowhead School Academy Trust138545 | Secondary | Good | 35.8% | 2,006 |
| Marlcliffe Community Primary School107000 | Primary | Good | 14.1% | 469 |
| Mansel Primary139137 | Primary | Good | 55.3% | 432 |
| Manor Lodge Community Primary and Nursery School143799 | Primary | Requires Improvement | 42.3% | 385 |
| Malin Bridge Primary School148868 | Primary | Outstanding | 19.6% | 615 |
| Lydgate Junior School106998 | Primary | Good | 11.2% | 482 |